Karen-Marie Schiøtt
Director
A merger is the most far-reaching change process an organisation can go through – and it places high demands on leadership. Entering a merger with this mindset is essential to getting the process right. It requires significant investment in a united leadership team and a new, shared culture to build the followership that makes the merger a success and delivers the expected synergies.
Several hundred merger and acquisition agreements are signed in Denmark every year, and activity has been rising over time – in Denmark and globally. Industries consolidate as the external environment shifts, driven by factors such as regulation and intensifying competition.
The pitfalls of mergers
Despite the growing number of mergers, a long line of studies shows that 60–90 per cent fail to realise the expected synergies. The reasons include poor handling of differing corporate cultures, slow decision-making and, quite simply, overly ambitious synergy targets.
There is no doubt that completing a merger successfully is difficult. So what can you, as a CEO, do to avoid the pitfalls? The answer is simple: treat the merger as a change process.
Three phases and three change tracks
A merger demands clear leadership, and a well-designed merger programme is critical. Structuring the programme around three overall phases and three change tracks provides the backbone for a successful integration (see Figure 1). The model should be seen as a game board: it can be adjusted and scaled to the type of transaction, from the acquisition of a smaller company to a large merger of equals.
Phase 1 – Integration planning: often during the standstill period leading up to approval from the competition authorities.
Phase 2 – The first 100 days: typically immediately after formal approval, when many of the most important projects are launched, synergies are pursued and a number of organisational changes are implemented.
Phase 3 – Post-merger integration and operations: when targets and synergies are delivered, the new shared culture is lived, and customers ideally experience no merger noise.
Investing heavily in Phase 1 is essential, both to realise the potential and to cement quickly what the new company is to be – which is why this article focuses on Phase 1. Many organisations only start in earnest after approval. You can, however, prepare in advance, within clear rules on what is permitted. Ideally, start as early as possible – but integration can also be done three years after approval. In other words, there is no excuse for not doing the work.
The change tracks are cross-cutting themes that run through every phase of the merger:
No merger succeeds without firm control of the long list of practical planning tasks that call for classic project management skills. That said, as a CEO you should devote at least as much attention to defining a shared direction, securing alignment in the leadership team and building a new culture.
We have repeatedly seen executives underestimate the importance of developing the new culture, simply because so many other things need to fall into place. Yet investing here is absolutely essential: cultural differences between the parties are one of the main reasons mergers fail. At the same time, keep a sharp focus on customers and competitors to avoid losing market share along the way.
Strategy: Set a clear direction early
Establishing key cornerstones early gives the leadership team a head start – naturally within the legal framework set by the competition authorities. Cornerstones allow you to communicate with one voice about where the future organisation is heading, and they reduce the uncertainty that is typically most acute early in a merger.
Creating a clear direction includes clarifying the new organisation’s identity: the shared business foundation and cultural bedrock that cuts across business areas and support functions. Its purpose is to make clear what you stand for as an organisation and what you are fighting for – including vision, mission and values.
Culture and leadership: Build a strong leadership team
In value-based leadership, the core is the set of values that frames the desired behaviour – anchored in a clear mission and vision. Values help leaders and employees alike behave at their best when meeting customers, colleagues and challenges.
The purpose of the culture and leadership track in this phase is to secure a high degree of cohesion and alignment in the top team. To build commitment to and ownership of the strategic cornerstones, the wider senior leadership group must also be involved. We recommend doing this through a series of workshops based on a proposal from the executive board.
Creating one leadership team with a shared spirit to lead the merger is the single most important success factor in building a solid foundation for integration – one of the key findings of our own CEO survey on transformations. Without strong, aligned leadership leading from the front, you will not move fast enough. Investing in team building and a strong sense of community in the leadership team is therefore central to replacing “us and them” with “we”.
Already in Phase 1, clear change management of employees and stakeholders is vital. Design a clear transformation programme for Phases 2 and 3, together with a clear operating model and group calendar – and launch the core narrative of the new company.
Naturally, what matters most to employees is clarity on whether they have a future in the company, and if so, in which role and on what terms. The staffing process is therefore a critical – and potentially explosive – piece of the puzzle. It must be based on clear design criteria that all leaders sign up to. If the criteria are clear enough, the process can be accelerated so that the top leadership layers are in place before formal approval, allowing the new organisation to go live internally soon after.
Synergy and integration: Understand the starting point and plan the future
The purpose of the synergy and integration track is to lay the foundation for realising synergies. First and foremost, clear programme ownership is essential, in a central integration management office reporting to the executive board. This secures progress and momentum, prioritisation alongside day-to-day operations, and cohesion across the organisation.
Do not underestimate the need for key resources. Dedicated project managers are important and should ideally be drawn from both parties. That way, it is not only the top team that is brought together along the way, but also the leadership layer below – which strengthens the change process.
For project managers to succeed, they need strong guidance and support from the centre, including shared tools and templates such as terms of reference, baseline analyses, organisational design and 100-day plans. Introducing these tools at workshops throughout the process builds a common understanding.
Finally, a high cadence of decisions is crucial. Frequent steering committee meetings with the executive board ensure fast decision-making, and firm control of governance and decision forums is essential to avoid decision paralysis and loss of momentum.
Nine vital pieces of advice for a successful merger
In short, merger work requires strong change leadership. To succeed, we recommend that you:
Director
Associate Partner
Senior Partner
Partner