Mikkel Eriksen
Senior Partner
Danish cooperatives are a success story in both Danish and international business. The cooperative is not an ownership model that we invented in Denmark, but no other country has embraced it to the same degree, or used it to create companies and jobs on a scale that shows up in the national accounts, as we have in Denmark. Here is the story.
The beginning
In Denmark, the cooperative movement is considered to have been born in 1866, when the first Danish consumer cooperative, Thisted Arbejderforening, was founded in Thisted by the dean Hans Christian Sonne.
The first ideas of a cooperative movement grew out of social indignation and date back to England in the late 18th century, at the same time as the Industrial Revolution. The basic idea was to create economic cooperation between people who were poorly off, in order to improve their living conditions.
In 1844, the first successful cooperative was founded by 28 poor weavers in Rochdale in the north of England. One of the cornerstones of that cooperative store, and of the cooperative movement from then on, was a set of principles based to a large extent on the ideas of the industrialist and social commentator Robert Owen (1771–1858) and the physician William King (1786–1865). The principles were that:
None of these 28 weavers could have gained anything like the same benefits on their own as they could by joining the community: a community they also co-owned and therefore helped to run and govern.
The benefits for the individual consumer were clear, and the cooperative stores quickly grew in number and membership. The idea soon reached Denmark too. In 1896, the Danish Cooperative Wholesale Society (FDB) was established, with the main aim of carrying out joint purchasing for the individual societies. FDB was the forerunner of what we know today as Coop amba, which runs a cooperative business based on the Rochdale principles, now almost 200 years old. Today, Coop amba has around 1.4 million members and a turnover of DKK 45 billion.
The cooperative idea had proved its success and durability among consumer businesses, but it did not stop there. Just a few years after the first cooperative stores in Denmark came the first cooperative dairies. Whereas the cooperative stores were an idea imported to and spread across Denmark, producer cooperatives such as the cooperative dairy appear to be a Danish invention. The first cooperative dairy, Hjedding Andelsmejeri, was founded in 1882.
The basic idea was that each dairy farmer could, and should, deliver his entire milk production to the dairy (what later became known as the obligation to buy and the obligation to deliver). As co-owner of the dairy, the dairy farmer received a share of any surplus in proportion to how much milk he had delivered. A dairy farmer with many cows thus received a larger share of the surplus than one with a small herd. But at the dairy’s general meeting, votes were counted by heads, not by herds: one man, one vote. The cooperative movement was democratic from the very beginning.
One of the aims of the cooperative dairies was to improve dairy farming. By joining forces, there was a larger quantity of milk to make dairy products from, and the dairies could afford to buy modern machinery and employ people trained in dairying. This meant products could be refined and sold at a higher price, while production became more efficient. Checks were also introduced to ensure that the animals were properly fed, and requirements were set for hygiene and milk storage, although these were rather simpler than today’s standards.
This laid the foundations for the business we know today as Arla Foods amba. Today, Arla Foods amba is owned by more than 12,500 dairy farmers in several European countries and has a turnover of close to DKK 80 billion.
Similar ideas and history lie behind the meat processing group Danish Crown (around 8,250 cooperative members and a turnover of around DKK 58 billion) and the agricultural company DLG (around 30,000 cooperative members and a turnover of around DKK 59 billion). Many utility companies are also built on the same cooperative principles. The cooperative idea and cooperative businesses delivered what many local communities were looking for: growth, development, jobs and stability.
In banking (including savings banks with guarantor capital), mortgage lending and insurance (mutual companies), the cooperative idea also became the basis for a number of businesses. Among the largest today is Nykredit. Foreningen Nykredit, whose members are the group’s borrowers, is the main shareholder in the Nykredit Group, which is the country’s largest lender with around 30 per cent of the Danish lending market.
The cooperative idea was born of social and economic indignation, but its success is inextricably linked to the agricultural reforms and industrialisation of the same period, and to the subsequent growth in private consumption and demand. The parallel with the development of democracy in Denmark and Europe is also crucial. Democratic ideas and principles therefore came to apply not only to how the country was governed, but also to many of its largest companies.
Today, Danish cooperatives do not play the same role in local communities as they once did. There is no longer a slaughterhouse and a dairy next to the cooperative store in every village. But the success of the cooperative idea should not be counted in the number of companies, but rather in the scale of their business, which is still considerable and built on success in both the Danish and the global market. Denmark, and no longer Thisted, is now the local community that supplies, and reaps the rewards of, the resources that flow into the cooperatives. The challenge for these giants of Danish business is to carry the fundamental cooperative principles forward in a global and digital world.
Producer-owned and consumer-owned cooperatives
Today, cooperatives do not rely on shared principles for running a business to the same extent as they once did. The business premise, however, remains that no individual member is large enough on their own to achieve the same economies of scale that the community can deliver. At the same time, there is a shared understanding that:
A central element of a cooperative is its business platform. Cooperatives are usually divided into producer-owned and consumer-owned cooperatives. Producer-owned cooperatives receive, process and sell their members’ production, for example dairies and slaughterhouses, while consumer-owned cooperatives serve their members with goods or services, for example retail and mortgage lending companies. In both cases, the company is owned by its members and run on democratic principles.
While all cooperatives share ownership and management of the business platform, there are differences in where the members sit in the value chain. In cooperatives that process products (for example, dairies and slaughterhouses), the members are suppliers. In cooperatives that provide goods and services, the members are usually the consumers of those goods and services (for example, cooperative stores and financial companies; the former are often referred to as consumer cooperatives).
In both cases, the members are individuals. In input companies, however, the members are also production businesses (for example, a farm) and therefore often act on the basis of a business rationale. In output companies, the consumer-owned cooperatives, the owners’ behaviour correspondingly reflects what might be called a consumer mindset.
Where the owners sit in the value chain challenges cooperatives in different ways. Cooperatives that process products must be managed and operate on the basis of the obligation to buy and deliver. This requires all the owners’ deliveries to be processed in a way that creates the greatest possible value for the owners as a whole, while also developing the company’s competitive position.
Similarly, consumer-owned cooperatives must make sure that the products and services they buy in and market to their owners match what other conventional competitors offer (for example, Dansk Supermarked). Today, members, and therefore consumers, can rarely be expected to pay a higher price than at competitors simply to maintain the cooperative community.
Because members of consumer-owned cooperatives have rarely contributed capital or ‘deposited’ their production in the cooperative, they are usually more interested in good offers than in the company’s long-term return on capital. It would probably be premature to claim that processing cooperatives are under greater pressure to generate earnings than consumer cooperatives, but there is a clear difference in what members of the two types focus on, and therefore in how the companies are run.
The type of cooperative can also affect how it chooses to invest, and how the rationale for those investments is presented to its members. Both types of business must constantly balance short-term value creation for their members with the company’s long-term development and the investment this requires.
When it comes to investment, cooperatives may be met with the counter-argument that ‘the money belongs in the members’ pockets’. On the other hand, many cooperatives have over the years managed to convince their members that investment-heavy initiatives such as mergers, acquisitions, innovation and entry into foreign markets were the only way forward to secure continued independence and survival.
This applies particularly to cooperatives with an obligation to buy and deliver. This dual obligation often works as a ‘blood pact’ with life itself at stake: if the cooperative does not survive, its members are unlikely to either. The individual member is simply financially dependent on the cooperative.
That is rarely the case with consumer-owned cooperatives. Here, the consumers, who are also the members, can usually find other suppliers of the goods and services in question without any significant extra cost. Often, what matters to members here is availability, for example access to groceries or capital in the local area.
Cooperative industries and sectors
Danish cooperatives have played, and still play, a crucial role in many industries and in the Danish economy as a whole. They contribute significant value creation, exports and employment, as well as local, regional and national activity.
From a global perspective, Danish cooperatives are doing well. The world’s 2,000 largest cooperatives have a combined turnover of more than USD 2,600 billion, of which almost USD 65 billion comes from Danish cooperatives alone. The 2,000 companies are active across six continents and operate mainly in agriculture and food (27 per cent), insurance (27 per cent), wholesale and retail (20 per cent) and industrial production (8 per cent).
In Denmark, cooperatively owned companies are still mainly found in:
The typical industries in which cooperatives are widespread have therefore not changed much since the late 19th century and up to the middle of the 20th century. To a greater extent, it is the consolidation of existing cooperatives that has shaped developments across industries. This trend has also applied across company forms, so it does not necessarily have anything to do with cooperatives as such.
The fact that there are still cooperatives in these various industries, and that they are often major players in their respective sectors, underlines how sustainable the cooperative is as a form of business.
The owners’ influence
In Denmark, a private business can be organised legally in different ways. This is referred to as the company’s form of ownership or business form. The most common forms of ownership are:
The aim here is not to go through the different forms of ownership from a legal perspective. But it is worth noting that the list above actually overlaps. A cooperative can be a general partnership (I/S), a limited partnership (K/S) or a company with limited liability (a cooperative with limited liability, or amba). The latter in particular must meet some very specific requirements, including that members must promote the company’s interests by supporting its operations as buyers, suppliers or similar.
The choice of ownership form has many legal and practical consequences and opportunities. But it does not necessarily say anything about how the owners actually exercise their ownership of the company. For example, there is a big difference between how ownership works in a family-owned company and in a listed company, even though both may be public limited companies.
Looking at the different forms of ownership from the perspective of how ownership exerts influence on the company highlights what is distinctive about cooperatives: ownership is spread across many members, with power and influence distributed equally. It is the democratic principle of one man, one vote that applies here.
This dispersed but equally distributed ownership creates different dynamics in the way ownership is exercised compared with, for example, listed companies. Listed companies also have dispersed ownership among shareholders, but the majority of shares are often held by a few shareholders, such as pension funds.
Put simply, for a cooperative to win backing for a decision at owner level, it needs the support of more than 50 per cent of its members, not just a few majority shareholders. That is crucial to how ownership works in a cooperative. Jan Skytte Pedersen, chair of Eniig amba, puts it like this:
‘There is greater patience among the owners of cooperatives, as you also see in many family-owned companies. But above all, the equality among the owners has been crucial to the success of the cooperative model.’
In practice, however, you also see a few individuals with particular influence in cooperatives. That influence is linked to their personality and their ability to build support and exert influence through other people, much as we know from members of the Danish Parliament.
Indeed, the comparison with political life is an obvious one. This is due to the distribution of voting power described above, where everyone is equal. But it is also due to the almost natural tendency that when many people come together around a cause, they often form sub-groups according to their views, perspectives and particular interests on a number of key issues.
In political life, we know these as political parties, which represent an official and recognised structure for grouping views. In cooperatives, it mainly happens around particular interests and can be more or less official, and vary from issue to issue. In agricultural cooperatives, for example, it is not unusual for organic farmers to pursue particular shared interests that more conventional members may not share. This may happen through official committees and councils, but rarely with any associated decision-making powers.
To understand how power is concentrated among the members, you need to know:
The key issues often concern:
There is fundamentally nothing strange about members holding different views on a number of key issues. This is also seen in other forms of ownership. Members themselves should, however, be aware of it, given that cohesion and decision-making power are two sides of the same coin in a cooperative. If members are too divided, it affects their ability to take and implement decisions.
The often extensive ownership structure of cooperatives can mean that, broadly speaking, they are somewhat slower to make decisions at owner level than other company forms. This is often offset by the fact that the longer decision-making process creates the framework for well-considered decisions viewed from several angles.
At the same time, in many situations the democratic decision-making process can be seen as equivalent to an implementation process for whatever is decided. The somewhat longer process, in which many parties must be consulted and members at the grassroots level are involved, often works as a way of explaining the rationale and consequences among the members.
When the decision is to be carried out by the owners (who are themselves either suppliers to or customers of the cooperative), they already know a great deal about it in advance. In this way, members are often very quick to follow a decision once it has been made. The ability to put decisions into effect quickly is often a significant competitive advantage.
If the fundamental cohesion disappears, however, the cooperative’s very survival is threatened. Without cohesion between members, or with only limited cohesion, the ability to take decisions, or to feel obliged to follow them, disappears or diminishes. The members’ ability to run the company is therefore closely tied to the cohesion among them.
Cohesion is not only a matter of basic agreement among members, but also of whether the cooperative ownership is active: that is, the extent to which members take part in official and unofficial meetings and activities, join discussions on the related online forums and so on. If the members, or most of them, are in reality inactive, both the quality and the legitimacy of the ownership’s decisions disappear.
Many cooperatives should therefore keep asking themselves whether their members are sufficiently involved in their ownership, both in number and in activity. The many active owners are the cornerstone of the company’s business foundation. Only if members cannot go elsewhere to sell or buy their products and services, in other words a near-monopoly, can the company survive inactive owners. Even then, only for a limited period, until new competing offers or solutions come along.
Senior Partner